25 conference athletes have been selected to the 2020-2021 All-Academic Conference.
| Name | School | Sports |
|---|---|---|
| Trevor Adamo | Ulster | Baseball |
| Logan Devries | Ulster | Baseball |
| Christian Diorio | Ulster | Baseball |
| Kevin Gutierrez | Ulster | Baseball |
| Andrew Villanueva | Dutchess | eSports |
| George Johnston | Dutchess | eSports |
| Bryant Caizachana | Dutchess | eSports |
| John M. McLain | Dutchess | eSports |
| Nathaniel Bogart | Dutchess | eSports |
| Paul Corey | Dutchess | eSports |
| Paul Letierri | Dutchess | eSports |
| Logan Heilfurth | Orange | Baseball |
| Sal Mecca | Orange | Baseball |
| Nelson Suarez | Orange | Baseball |
| Gregory Bandura | Orange | Baseball |
| Eli Bontrager | Orange | Baseball |
| Casey Dailey | Orange | Baseball |
| Shawn Sawyer | Orange | Baseball |
| Emily Wangenstein | Orange | Softball |
| Amanda Miller | Orange | Softball |
| Sarah Haglund | Orange | Softball |
| Chloe Jamieson | Orange | Softball |
| Faith Faber | Orange | Softball |
| Tyler Miller | Orange | Golf |
